Author(s): Piety Godwill Suku, Ejikeme Ugwoha and Ochuko Felix Orikpete*
ABSTRACT
Artisanal crude oil refining remains a significant environmental and health challenge in the Niger Delta. This review examines the long-term impacts of this unregulated practice, focusing on pollution pathways, community health outcomes, ecosystem degradation, and socioeconomic factors that sustain this illicit industry. We assess the extent of air, water, and soil contamination resulting from artisanal refining processes and identify the pollution pathways that contribute to elevated risks for respiratory illnesses, cancer, reproductive disorders, and other health issues within local populations. Additionally, we explore the degradation of local biodiversity and ecosystem health, illustrating the adverse effects on flora, fauna, and traditional livelihoods. Socioeconomic factors, including poverty and limited regulatory enforcement, exacerbate these health and environmental consequences. Finally, we review mitigation strategies and policy approaches aimed at reducing the adverse effects of artisanal refining while considering the socioeconomic realities of affected communities. This review provides comprehensive insights into the scale and complexity of the issue, highlighting the urgent need for holistic, community-driven solutions that address the environmental and health ramifications in the Niger Delta region.
The Niger Delta, located in southern Nigeria, is one of the world’s richest oil-producing regions, supplying a significant portion of Nigeria’s crude oil exports [1]. This area is characterized by a vast network of rivers, mangrove forests, and swamps that form a unique and fragile ecosystem. Home to diverse ethnic communities, the Niger Delta has historically relied on fishing and agriculture for livelihoods [2]. However, the discovery and extraction of oil transformed the region into an economic hub [3]. Despite its vast natural wealth, the Niger Delta faces challenges such as environmental pollution, poverty, and socio-political unrest, which are often exacerbated by artisanal oil refining activities [4,5].
Artisanal refining, commonly referred to as “kpo-fire” in local parlance, involves boiling crude oil and collecting the resultant fumes, which are condensed in tanks and utilized locally for lighting, fuel, and transportation purposes [6]. The makeshift distilleries are heated using open fires fueled by crude oil, which is poured into pits in the ground. As the oil burns, some of it infiltrates the soil, potentially contaminating underground aquifers [7]. The refining process generates dense clouds of soot and gaseous compounds that are released into the environment, alongside unprocessed portions. Significant amounts of air pollutants, such as carbon black and soot, are produced, primarily containing polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) [8-10]. These pollutants pose substantial environmental and health risks to local communities, as they have been linked to carcinogenic effects and tissue toxicity [11]. The unregulated release of these compounds poses a significant health and developmental threat to the surrounding population [12].
Artisanal refining emerged as a response to socio-economic challenges such as poverty, unemployment, and a lack of access to formal economic opportunities [13]. This activity involves the crude and often unsafe processing of oil using makeshift refineries, leading to significant environmental pollution and adverse health effects on surrounding communities [14]. The widespread prevalence of artisanal refining has resulted in the contamination of air, water, and soil resources, posing severe risks to biodiversity and the health of local populations. Despite being a primary economic activity for some, this practice has resulted in a dramatic decline in ecosystem health and public well-being, requiring urgent intervention.
Numerous studies have addressed various aspects of the environmental impacts of artisanal refining. For instance, research conducted by focused on the persistent organic pollutants and their distribution within affected ecosystems, highlighting how these compounds degrade environmental quality and threaten human health [15]. Similarly, the study by provided insights into the specific pathways through which air pollution from artisanal refining exacerbates respiratory diseases and other health problems [11]. These studies, while insightful, often focus narrowly on either environmental or health aspects without integrating socioeconomic drivers.
Extended this discussion by examining the regulatory and governance challenges that enable the persistence of artisanal refining despite known risks [16]. While their analysis delves into the legal framework, it stops short of connecting these governance issues with direct health and environmental outcomes. Another significant contribution by detailed the direct impact of artisanal refining on local water quality and the subsequent effects on community health metrics such as disease prevalence and mortality rates [17].
Previous studies have extensively explored the environmental and health impacts of artisanal refining, focusing on pollution pathways, ecosystem degradation, and health outcomes in the Niger Delta. However, none of these studies have comprehensively combined the socioeconomic factors driving this practice with the interrelated environmental and health effects to propose actionable mitigation strategies. This review aims to synthesize existing knowledge regarding the environmental, socioeconomic, and health impacts of artisanal refining in the Niger Delta, providing a comprehensive analysis of pollution pathways and their effects. By identifying the specific vectors through which pollution from artisanal refining contributes to respiratory illnesses, cancer, reproductive disorders, and other health challenges in local communities, this study seeks to bridge the gap between scientific evidence and actionable strategies. It will also examine the degradation of biodiversity and loss of traditional livelihoods resulting from ecosystem disruption. By considering the socioeconomic drivers that sustain this practice, we will offer a clearer understanding of the broader context and challenges associated with curbing artisanal refining.
The review will follow a structured format to comprehensively address the subject matter. Section 2 will detail the materials and methods used to gather and analyze the relevant data. Section 3 will explore pollution pathways, emphasizing air, water, and soil contamination linked to artisanal refining. Section 4 will examine health outcomes, detailing illnesses, and disorders prevalent in the region. Section 5 will assess the environmental and socioeconomic outcomes arising from artisanal refining. Section 6 will discuss mitigation and policy strategies, evaluating current frameworks and proposing new approaches. Finally, Section 7 will summarize key findings, provide recommendations, and highlight future research and policy focus.
This systematic review was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines [18]. Our objective was to synthesize existing research on the environmental and health impacts of artisanal crude oil refining in the Niger Delta, focusing on pollution pathways, community health outcomes, and the efficacy of current interventions.
We performed a comprehensive literature search using multiple electronic databases, including PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. The search was limited to studies published in English from January 2000 to March 2024. Keywords used included “artisanal refining,” “crude oil,” “Niger Delta,” “environmental pollution,” “health impacts,” and related terms. We also manually searched the references of included studies to identify additional relevant publications. Studies were included if they provided data on environmental or health impacts related to artisanal crude oil refining in the Niger Delta. We included observational studies, case reports, and review articles. Exclusion criteria were studies not directly relevant to the Niger Delta or artisanal refining, editorials, and opinion pieces.
Two reviewers independently extracted data from the included studies using a standardized data extraction form. Extracted information included study location, study design, population characteristics, types of pollutants studied, health outcomes measured, and key findings. Discrepancies between reviewers were resolved through discussion or by consulting a third reviewer. The quality of included studies was assessed using the Risk of Bias in Systematic reviews (ROBIS) tool for systematic reviews and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for observational studies [19,20]. This assessment helped evaluate the reliability of the findings and the degree of bias in the studies included in our review. Data were synthesized qualitatively due to the heterogeneity of study designs and outcomes. We grouped findings into thematic categories based on the type of pollution (air, water, soil) and health impacts reported. We also evaluated the effectiveness of reported mitigation strategies and their implementation challenges. As this study is a systematic review of published literature, it did not require ethical approval. All analyses were based on previously published data, and no new human participants were involved.
Artisanal refining in the Niger Delta contributes significantly to environmental pollution. Understanding these pollution pathways is crucial for assessing the extent of damage and devising effective mitigation strategies.
Artisanal refining primarily affects air quality due to the emission of pollutants through open burning processes. Makeshift distilleries, lacking any form of pollution control, release significant quantities of particulate matter, soot, and hazardous gases directly into the atmosphere. These emissions are laden with carbon black, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and other toxic compounds that severely degrade air quality [11]. PAHs, known for their persistence in the environment and bioaccumulative potential, pose a significant ecological threat and can have long- term consequences on health [21]. These toxic compounds become particularly dangerous due to their ability to remain suspended in the atmosphere and travel long distances.
The open burning of crude oil produces dense clouds of soot and toxic gases that spread widely across surrounding communities. This results in a marked increase in ambient concentrations of fine particulate matter and airborne toxins. These emissions can significantly deteriorate air quality, as evidenced by increasing rates of respiratory ailments in nearby populations [17]. Fine particulates can penetrate deep into the respiratory system, while PAHs exacerbate this risk by adhering to these particles, compounding health hazards, particularly among vulnerable groups such as children and the elderly [22]. Moreover, exposure to these pollutants is associated with heightened risks of asthma, bronchitis, and cardiovascular diseases.
Recent research indicates that the long-term impact of these emissions extends beyond immediate health concerns, contributing to chronic diseases and potential genetic mutations over time. The cumulative effect of continuous exposure to such pollutants can overwhelm the immune system and compromise the overall well- being of affected communities. Moreover, the chemical emissions released into the atmosphere from artisanal refining is highly variable, posing unique challenges for monitoring and managing pollution sources. The concentration of hazardous pollutants, including volatile organic compounds, sulphur dioxide, and nitrogen oxides, necessitates a concerted effort to curtail emissions.
It is evident from the above discussions that artisanal refining produces an array of pollutants that spread via complex air pathways, exposing surrounding populations to substantial health risks. The open burning of crude oil and waste products exacerbates these dangers, underscoring the need for effective interventions that address both pollution control and community health safeguards.
The spillage of crude oil from artisanal refineries and pipelines in the Niger Delta region is a critical environmental issue with profound implications for aquatic ecosystems. Artisanal refining activities contaminate water through multiple channels, such as discharges from nearshore operations, industrial effluents, accidental spills during loading, and leaking pipelines. Further contamination arises from illegal well tapping, rudimentary refining processes, and ballast water from oil tankers [23]. These activities introduce harmful substances, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), benzene, and other carcinogenic compounds, which pose severe risks to both the environment and public health [15].
Moreover, crude oil pollution drastically affects soil and water quality by altering their physicochemical properties and destroying vegetation cover, resulting in the release of toxic hydrocarbons into the environment [24]. Contamination severely impacts the microbiological properties of soil and water, disturbing the growth dynamics of microorganisms that play essential roles in nutrient cycling and ecosystem functioning [17]. These changes compromise the delicate balance of aquatic ecosystems, leading to a decline in biodiversity and creating long-term disruptions in ecological stability.
Oil spills are frequent due to rudimentary refining processes and a lack of containment measures. These spills release crude oil into rivers, streams, and wetlands, contaminating surface and groundwater systems. Groundwater aquifers, which are crucial sources of drinking water for many communities, are particularly vulnerable to seepage contamination [25]. This not only renders the water unfit for human consumption but also increases the bioaccumulation of harmful chemicals in aquatic organisms.
The accumulation of hydrocarbons and other toxic substances in aquatic ecosystems is linked to mass fish mortality and disruptions in amphibian life cycles. Contamination directly impacts local fisheries, reducing catches and threatening the livelihoods of fishing communities. Furthermore, the scarcity of clean water forces communities to rely on polluted sources, resulting in widespread waterborne diseases and adverse health outcomes [26].
The impact of water pollution from artisanal refining is compounded by seasonal flooding, which disperses contaminants across broader regions, affecting farmlands and residential areas. The widespread contamination threatens the region’s already fragile food and water security, perpetuating health challenges and socio-economic disparities. Addressing this crisis requires a comprehensive approach, focusing on pollution containment, refining process regulation, and community education to reduce the long-term ecological and health effects.
During the artisanal refining process, crude oil often seeps into the ground, contaminating soil with hydrocarbon residues and hazardous pollutants. This contamination significantly alters the soil’s physical and chemical properties, including raising soil pH levels and reducing phosphorus content [27]. These changes create an environment unsuitable for agriculture, as persistent organic pollutants and heavy metals penetrate several meters deep, rendering the soil toxic and unfit for cultivation. Additionally, the penetration of oil can contaminate groundwater sources over large areas, posing severe health risks to local communities [15].
The eco-toxicological impacts of pollutants released during artisanal refining processes further deteriorate soil quality, adversely affecting the diverse microbial communities that maintain soil health and fertility [28]. This contamination not only impairs soil microorganisms essential for nutrient cycling but also leads to an accumulation of hydrocarbons and other pollutants in the environment. Such accumulation is primarily attributed to artisanal refining activities, which have been identified as a major anthropogenic source of hydrocarbon pollution in soil and water [29].
Soil contamination directly impacts agricultural productivity, as crops absorb toxic substances from the soil, leading to stunted growth and reduced yields. This undermines food security for local communities, as the loss of crop yield compounds the existing scarcity of resources. Furthermore, the persistent contamination renders previously arable land unsuitable for cultivation or other productive uses, forcing farmers to abandon their plots. The abandonment of arable land, combined with declining agricultural production, exacerbates poverty and deepens the socio-economic disparities in the Niger Delta.
Moreover, soil pollution from artisanal refining has ripple effects beyond agriculture. The abandonment of contaminated land disrupts traditional livelihoods and forces affected populations to seek alternative means of subsistence, often turning to precarious and hazardous work. These shifts contribute to the cycle of poverty and create long-term socio-economic challenges. Combating soil contamination requires a coordinated response involving comprehensive regulation of artisanal refining processes, land remediation strategies, and community outreach programs to mitigate the environmental and health consequences effectively.
The unregulated nature of artisanal refining in the Niger Delta has created significant health risks for local communities. Prolonged exposure to pollutants generated from these operations affects’ multiple aspects of human health, including respiratory function, cancer prevalence, and reproductive health. Below is an analysis of some key health outcomes:
Communities living near artisanal crude oil refining sites suffer constant exposure to high levels of air pollution due to the open burning of crude oil and waste materials. This practice releases significant quantities of soot, fine particulate matter, and gaseous compounds, causing substantial air quality degradation [30]. Among these pollutants, fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and sulphur dioxide pose severe health risks as these microscopic particles penetrate deep into the respiratory system, causing inflammation and worsening pre-existing conditions like asthma and bronchitis [31]. The health impact is particularly critical because of the widespread prevalence of artisanal refining in the region, where weak regulatory controls contribute to the unchecked release of pollutants. These issues are exacerbated by a lack of access to proper healthcare facilities, leaving many to suffer from untreated and worsening respiratory illnesses.
The impact of these pollutants is especially severe in vulnerable demographic groups like children and the elderly, who have developing or weakened immune systems [32]. Prolonged exposure to these pollutants results in chronic bronchitis, asthma, and other upper respiratory conditions [33,34]. This long-term exposure also significantly increases the risk of developing chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), which manifests through persistent coughing, wheezing, and shortness of breath [35]. The combination of compromised air quality and inadequate medical infrastructure exacerbates these conditions, leading to prolonged suffering and reduced quality of life for affected individuals. The daily challenges faced by these vulnerable populations highlight the severity of the health impacts associated with artisanal refining.
The health implications extend beyond respiratory conditions, as exposure to these pollutants is also linked to cardiovascular problems [36,37]. The fine particles released through artisanal refining induce systemic inflammation and oxidative stress, which increases the likelihood of heart disease and related complications [38]. Pregnant women exposed to high pollution levels are at greater risk of preterm births and low birth weights, which can have lasting consequences on infant health and development [39,40]. In addition, the systemic inflammation caused by fine particulate matter can exacerbate existing cardiovascular conditions, further increasing health risks for those with pre-existing vulnerabilities [41].
The prevalence of respiratory illnesses and associated health conditions among populations living near artisanal refineries is alarming. It underscores the urgency of mitigating pollution to protect the health of these communities, where the unregulated burning of crude oil not only affects immediate respiratory health but also contributes to broader cardiovascular and developmental issues. The evidence emphasizes the critical need for comprehensive interventions aimed at safeguarding public health and improving air quality in the Niger Delta region. Effective measures should involve multi-sectoral efforts that bring together regulatory bodies, healthcare providers, and community stakeholders to develop solutions that are both feasible and sustainable.
Artisanal crude oil refining emits a diverse array of carcinogenic compounds, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), benzene, and other hazardous chemicals. These substances are highly toxic and elevate the risk of multiple cancers, including lung, liver, and skin cancers. PAHs, particularly hazardous due to their persistence in the environment and tendency to bioaccumulate in the food chain, are of special concern [42-44]. Persistent exposure to PAHs affects DNA integrity, promoting mutations that contribute to cancer development. These carcinogens also pose a risk to nearby communities through contaminated water and food supplies [45]. The research highlights the need for comprehensive monitoring and environmental protection measures to mitigate cancer risks in these vulnerable populations.
The risk of cancer is exacerbated by benzene exposure, which is strongly associated with leukemia and various blood disorders [46]. Prolonged contact with benzene can impair the immune system, leaving individuals vulnerable to infections and diseases.
Benzene, an easily absorbed and metabolized compound, has a systemic impact, particularly affecting bone marrow, leading to severe blood cell anomalies. Found that skin exposure to crude oil and its derivatives further increases the risk of skin cancers or dermatitis. These findings underscore the multifaceted cancer risks present in the Niger Delta due to artisanal refining, necessitating stronger health and safety regulations [47].
Additionally, reproductive health disorders are prevalent among individuals frequently exposed to pollutants from artisanal refining. Heavy metals, such as lead and cadmium, disrupt endocrine function and hormonal balances, contributing to infertility in men and women [48]. Demonstrated that exposure to these metals during pregnancy results in higher rates of miscarriage, preterm births, and significant developmental delays in children [49]. Argued that exposure to pollutants like cadmium severely affects sperm health, causing decreased motility and increased DNA fragmentation in men. These effects not only affect individual health but also have broader implications for public health and population growth, necessitating targeted reproductive health interventions [50].
Moreover, emphasized that the cumulative effects of these pollutants, alongside other social determinants of health, disproportionately impact women and children in artisanal refining areas [51]. The presence of these carcinogens and heavy metals is linked to developmental delays, cognitive impairments, and various congenital disabilities, requiring comprehensive community health strategies to alleviate these consequences. Addressing these reproductive health challenges calls for extensive efforts to provide clean environments and equitable access to health care for affected communities.
These cumulative findings highlight the profound health impacts stemming from artisanal refining activities. Implementing robust monitoring systems, combined with regulatory frameworks and healthcare interventions, is essential to address the cancer and reproductive health challenges facing the Niger Delta’s most vulnerable populations.
Artisanal refining in the Niger Delta not only causes respiratory and cancer-related illnesses but also significantly contributes to a broader spectrum of health issues. Mental health disorders, such as depression, anxiety, and stress, have been documented with alarming frequency among communities directly impacted by oil pollution [52-54]. The environmental devastation and subsequent erosion of traditional livelihoods have driven many into psychological despair. Displaced farmers and fishermen, once reliant on the land and waterways, now struggle with joblessness and economic instability, resulting in chronic mental health challenges that are compounded by a lack of access to psychological care. These conditions are exacerbated by the social stigma surrounding mental illness, preventing many from seeking help.
In addition, frequent oil spills and pollution of water sources have led to recurring outbreaks of waterborne diseases, like cholera and typhoid fever, which remain persistent threats to public health in the region [55,56]. Contaminated water sources, stemming from industrial waste and oil residues, have left many communities without access to clean drinking water, significantly raising their exposure to pathogens. This lack of clean water has also undermined basic sanitation practices, leading to further health risks and disproportionately impacting children, who are most vulnerable to these diseases. Inadequate healthcare infrastructure exacerbates the problem, with many affected communities located far from primary health services.
Moreover, neurological effects, particularly among children, have raised significant concerns. Heavy metal contamination from artisanal refining has introduced lead, cadmium, and mercury into the environment, resulting in cognitive impairments, learning disabilities, and behavioral issues [57,58]. The long-term exposure to these toxic substances accumulates over time, causing irreversible damage to neurodevelopment and reducing future educational attainment. Studies have highlighted the prevalence of diminished IQ levels and neurodevelopmental delays in affected areas, emphasizing the need for immediate intervention.
Chronic exposure to these pollutants is also linked to a range of metabolic disorders, cardiovascular diseases, and immune system dysfunctions, making it a multi-dimensional health crisis [48,51]. Continuous exposure to these heavy metals and chemical pollutants weakens the immune system, leaving individuals vulnerable to chronic illnesses like diabetes and hypertension. Women, children, and the elderly face the highest risks due to their physiological vulnerabilities and limited socio-economic resilience.
The cumulative health impacts of artisanal refining activities in the Niger Delta call for a comprehensive and coordinated response. Intervention strategies should include improved public health initiatives that address the water crisis and provide access to healthcare while fostering economic support programs to offer alternative livelihood opportunities. Such measures will help reduce the burden of pollution on health and bolster community resilience against future environmental threats.
Artisanal refining activities in the Niger Delta have inflicted significant damage on the region’s biodiversity and ecosystems. Oil pollution affects plant and animal life, and these impacts have far-reaching consequences on local communities and their traditional livelihoods.
The Niger Delta is renowned for its rich biodiversity, consisting of mangrove forests, wetlands, and rivers. However, artisanal refining has inflicted severe damage on this delicate ecosystem due to frequent oil spills and gas flaring, which have led to the contamination of soil, water, and air. The accumulation of hydrocarbons and heavy metals in the environment has caused widespread degradation of plant life. Specifically, mangrove trees, crucial for ecosystem stability and as breeding grounds for marine species, have been significantly impacted. Their loss has a domino effect on the food chain, contributing to the decline of herbivorous and omnivorous species.
Studies have shown that oil pollution from artisanal refining impairs seed germination and stunts plant growth, with negative consequences for local vegetation [59,60]. Heavy metals from spent engine oil and other pollutants accumulate in plants, disrupting essential metabolic processes and causing harm [61]. The elemental uptake of plants is also affected, altering nutrient balances and microbial populations in the soil [62]. Moreover, petroleum contamination has varying effects on different plant families, with some more sensitive than others [63]. Nanomaterial degradation of oil pollutants has been explored as a remediation strategy to minimize harmful effects on plant life [64].
The effects of oil pollution from artisanal refining extend into aquatic ecosystems, posing a significant threat to marine biology and ecology [65]. Pollutants released from artisanal refining activities contaminate water bodies and wetlands, directly harming aquatic life [66]. Fish populations, integral to the local diet and economy, have dwindled due to toxins in their habitats [26]. Amphibians, birds, and other animals that rely on wetlands and mangrove forests have lost their breeding grounds or seen them become highly polluted, resulting in mass migrations and population declines. Wildlife diversity has suffered a considerable decline, with many species facing extinction [67].
Oil pollution from artisanal refining disrupts wildlife biology by impairing reproduction, development, and overall health [68]. Disruptions to reproductive physiology, sexual communication, gamete quality, and parental care are some of the observed effects. Endocrine-disrupting chemicals in oil pollution interfere with vital systems, leading to developmental and reproductive disorders [69]. Hypoxia caused by oil pollution affects fish reproduction, which ripples through wildlife populations [70]. Endocrine disruption due to contaminants can impair developmental, behavioral, and reproductive systems in wildlife [71]. The survival of wildlife populations is threatened by exposure to oil pollution, not only directly but also indirectly via ingestion, inhalation, and absorption, resulting in physiological effects [72]. These wide- ranging effects underscore the need for targeted interventions to mitigate the environmental degradation affecting both flora and fauna in the Niger Delta.
The Niger Delta region is home to a unique ecosystem and vibrant communities, yet the socioeconomic impact of artisanal refining has been devastating. The practice’s adverse effects have infiltrated nearly every facet of life in the region, encompassing agriculture, fisheries, employment, healthcare, and social dynamics.
Fishing communities have borne a significant portion of the burden resulting from artisanal refining, as oil spills and gas flaring have contaminated rivers and coastal waters. This pollution has drastically reduced fish populations and destroyed crucial breeding habitats. Documented how fish scarcity has crippled the income of local fishermen and compromised household food security [73]. The degradation of aquatic environments not only reduces the availability of seafood but also affects the ecological balance, impacting local economies and forcing residents to migrate in search of alternative livelihoods. Furthermore, the seasonal floods that carry pollutants into fishing areas exacerbate contamination, creating long-term economic instability [53].
Farming communities have similarly suffered, as farmlands near artisanal refining sites have been contaminated by oil spills and gas flaring. These pollutants contain high levels of hydrocarbons and heavy metals that leave farmlands unusable. Emphasized how oil pollution has stunted crop growth and reduced yields, resulting in severe financial hardship for farmers [74]. As a result, many farming households experience reduced income, further aggravating the region’s food security crisis. With fewer viable agricultural options, families face significant challenges, including the risk of displacement and economic vulnerability.
The destruction of traditional livelihoods has resulted in widespread unemployment and poverty throughout the Niger Delta. As fishing and farming opportunities dwindle, many individuals are forced to depend on subsistence activities or seek alternative sources of income. Noted that this shift often leads to participation in unsafe or unsustainable employment, which further destabilizes the local economy [75]. This economic instability manifests itself in rising social tensions, as competition for scarce resources leads to disputes over land access, water rights, and other communal concerns.
Healthcare facilities in the region have been stretched to their limits due to the prevalence of pollution-related diseases. Artisanal refining often results in toxic chemical exposure, leading to a rise in respiratory illnesses, cancers, and reproductive disorders [76]. Examined how the financial burden of treating these conditions exacerbated the existing economic hardship in affected communities [77]. Additionally, reduced income leaves many families unable to afford preventive healthcare or medical treatment, worsening the public health crisis.
The adverse socioeconomic consequences of artisanal refining have disrupted social dynamics in the Niger Delta. The loss of traditional livelihoods has forced many into alternative employment, often resulting in hazardous working conditions or illegal activities. Highlighted how this phenomenon fosters insecurity and poverty, perpetuating a cycle that further destabilizes the region [78]. Argued that without sustainable economic alternatives and comprehensive health interventions, the socioeconomic stability and development of the Niger Delta will remain at risk [79].
We can clearly see from these studies that the socioeconomic impact of artisanal refining is profound and multifaceted, affecting traditional livelihoods, health, social stability, and economic development. Addressing these issues requires urgent intervention, focused on environmental restoration and providing sustainable, alternative livelihoods to support the region’s economic recovery and social well-being.
Mitigating the negative impact of artisanal refining in the Niger Delta requires comprehensive strategies. Current and proposed solutions involve stricter regulations, community-driven initiatives, technological innovations, and sustainable economic alternatives.
Several regulatory frameworks and enforcement strategies have been implemented at national and regional levels to tackle the problem of illegal refining activities and their environmental impacts. Environmental protection laws and guidelines are in place to penalize individuals or groups involved in illegal refining and pollution [80]. Security agencies regularly conduct raids to dismantle illegal refining sites and deter further operations. However, these frameworks face significant challenges, particularly in the enforcement phase. Corruption among some government officials, security personnel, and local leaders undermines efforts to uphold these laws and hinders effective site dismantling operations [16]. Moreover, logistical issues, including the inaccessibility of remote refining locations and the lack of sufficient resources, further impair enforcement, enabling illicit operations to persist.
Environmental monitoring is another cornerstone of current strategies. Government agencies, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and international organizations conduct monitoring activities to gauge pollution levels and identify contamination hotspots. The data collected through these efforts form the basis for targeted cleanup initiatives, providing valuable insight into the ecological impacts of artisanal refining [81]. However, these initiatives often lack adequate funding, resulting in inconsistent monitoring and limited implementation of recommendations.
Without a comprehensive and sustained monitoring network, data gaps hinder the development of effective, data-driven interventions.
Despite the existence of these strategies, current approaches fall short due to systemic issues in governance and implementation. Corruption remains a central problem, as it undermines the credibility and efficacy of enforcement measures. Additionally, local communities often lack alternative livelihoods, prompting many to continue illegal refining operations out of economic necessity. Social and economic instability in the region perpetuates this cycle of dependency on illicit activities, further complicating intervention efforts.
Inadequate community engagement and education also play a role in the ineffectiveness of existing strategies. Many local inhabitants may not fully comprehend the long-term health and environmental consequences of artisanal refining or understand alternative sources of income. Therefore, addressing the artisanal refining problem requires a holistic approach that emphasizes both regulatory enforcement and sustainable economic alternatives while combating corruption and improving community engagement.
Addressing the pervasive issue of artisanal refining in the Niger Delta requires a multi-pronged approach that involves local communities, technological innovation, and economic transformation. Engaging local communities is fundamental for sustainable change. Education programs can raise awareness among residents about the environmental and health dangers of artisanal refining. Local leaders, traditional rulers, and NGOs can play a pivotal role in creating community-based surveillance networks that empower people to identify and report illicit refining activities. By fostering grassroots participation, these programs can build local ownership over anti-refining measures. In parallel, alternative livelihood programs should be developed to encourage economic activities that discourage illegal refining. Community workshops and training can provide skills in agriculture, aquaculture, renewable energy, and other industries to help individuals find meaningful and sustainable employment.
Also, technological advancements are vital for reducing pollution and managing refining activities more effectively. Developing and deploying safer refining practices can help minimize emissions and the risk of oil spills. Advanced equipment for oil cleanup and remediation will enhance environmental restoration efforts by precisely targeting pollutants. Data analytics and remote sensing technologies should also be employed to monitor illegal refining sites and track pollution dispersion. With these tools, authorities can prioritize high-risk areas for targeted intervention and remediation.
Moreover, breaking the cycle of artisanal refining requires the creation of viable, sustainable economic alternatives. Job training programs that equip people with skills relevant to industries outside the oil sector are critical. Investments in sectors like agriculture, aquaculture, renewable energy, and eco-tourism can foster job growth and reduce dependence on illicit activities. Furthermore, improving access to finance and resources for local entrepreneurs can help them develop small businesses that support local economies sustainably.
Additionally, strengthening regulatory enforcement is imperative to disrupt the illicit refining network. Authorities must address corruption by increasing accountability measures for security agencies and government officials. Monitoring frameworks must be reinforced, leveraging technology to enhance transparency. Increasing penalties for illegal refining and implementing stringent guidelines can deter repeat offenders. However, enforcement should be conducted alongside community engagement to maintain local support and avoid alienating marginalized populations.
A holistic approach that combines stronger regulatory enforcement with community engagement, technological innovation, and sustainable economic opportunities is essential. Governments, NGOs, and private stakeholders should collaborate to create comprehensive strategies that address the root causes of artisanal refining while protecting the environment and improving the socioeconomic landscape of the Niger Delta. By adopting this multifaceted approach, we can curtail artisanal refining and pave the way for a healthier, more prosperous region [82-84].
Artisanal refining in the Niger Delta poses severe environmental and health challenges due to the lack of regulation and hazardous refining methods. The practice results in significant air pollution, water contamination, and soil degradation, which adversely impact respiratory health, increase cancer risks, and harm biodiversity and traditional livelihoods. Socioeconomic factors, regulatory weaknesses, and community dynamics perpetuate these challenges. Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive approach. Recommendations include strengthening regulatory frameworks, improving environmental monitoring, and developing community-driven solutions. Technological interventions can minimize pollution, while sustainable economic alternatives are necessary to create viable livelihoods and discourage illegal refining activities.
Future research should focus on understanding the health impacts and long-term ecological damage from artisanal refining. Research into innovative pollution control technologies, economic empowerment programs, and community-based monitoring systems will also prove valuable. Ultimately, policymakers and stakeholders must collaborate to develop strategies that prioritize human health, environmental conservation, and socioeconomic development to address this multifaceted problem.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate: Not applicable
Consent for Publication: Not applicable.
Availability of Data and Materials: Not applicable.
Competing Interests: The authors declare that they have no competing interests, financial or non-financial, that could be perceived as influencing the content or conclusions of this paper.
Funding:No funding was obtained for this study.
Acknowledgements: Not applicable
1.Onuh PA, Omenma TJ, Onyishi CJ, Udeogu CU, Nkalu NC, et al. (2021) Artisanal refining of crude oil in the Niger Delta: A challenge to clean-up and remediation in Ogoniland. Local Economy 36: 468-486.
2.Ogbeibu AE, Oribhabor BJ (2023) The Niger Delta mangrove ecosystem and its conservation challenges. In Mangrove biology, ecosystem, and conservation. https://doi.org/10.5772/ intechopen.112543
3.Idemudia U, Ite UE (2006) Demystifying the Niger Delta conflict: Towards an integrated explanation. Review of African Political Economy 33: 391-406.
4.Anejionu OC, Ahiarammunnah PAN, Nri ezedi CJ (2015) Hydrocarbon pollution in the Niger Delta: Geographies of impacts and appraisal of lapses in extant legal framework. Resources Policy 45: 65-77.
5.Ewim DRE, Orikpete OF, Scott TO, Onyebuchi CN, Onukogu AO, et al. (2023) Survey of wastewater issues due to oil spills and pollution in the Niger Delta area of Nigeria: a secondary data analysis. Bulletin of the National Research Centre 47: 116-136.
6.Suku PG, Ugwoha E, Orikpete OF, Ewim DRE (2023) Assessment of respiratory and reproductive impacts of artisanal refinery activities on male Albino Wistar rats: implications for environmental health. Bulletin of the National Research Centre 47: 149-176.
7.Amangabara GT, Njoku JD (2012) Assessing groundwater vulnerability to the activities of artisanal refining in Bolo and environs, Ogu/Bolo Local Government Area of Rivers State; Nigeria. British Journal of Environment and Climate Change 2: 28-36.
8.Howard IC, Azuatola OD, Abiodun IK (2017) Investigation on impacts of artisanal refining of crude oil on river bed sediments. Our Nature 15: 34-43.
9.Niranjan R, Thakur AK (2017) The toxicological mechanisms of environmental soot (black carbon) and carbon black: focus on oxidative stress and inflammatory pathways. Frontiers in Immunology 8: 01-20.
10.Nwankwoala HO, Harry MT, Amangabara GT, Warmate T (2017) Impacts of artisanal refining activities on soil and water quality in parts of Okrika and Ogu-Bolo areas of Rivers State, Nigeria. Journal of Scientific Achievements 2: 13-19.
11.Ephraim Emmanuel BC, Enembe O, Ordinioha B (2023) Respiratory health effects of pollution due to artisanal crude- oil refining in Bayelsa, Nigeria. Annals of Global Health 89: 01-11.
12.Yabrade M, Tanee FBG (2016) Assessing the impact of artisanal petroleum refining on vegetation and soil quality: A case study of Warri South West Salt Wetland of Delta State, Nigeria. Environmental Toxicology 10: 205-212.
13.Adekola O, Mitchell G (2011) The Niger Delta wetlands: threats to ecosystem services, their importance to dependent communities and possible management measures. International Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services & Management 7: 50-68.
14.Sojinu SO, Ejeromedoghene O (2019) Environmental challenges associated with processing of heavy crude oils. In Processing of heavy crude oils - Challenges and opportunities. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.82605
15.Lindén O, Pålsson J (2013) Oil contamination in Ogoniland, Niger Delta. Ambio 42: 685-701.
16.Olujobi OJ, Olarinde ES, Yebisi TE (2022) The Conundrums of Illicit Crude Oil Refineries in Nigeria and Its Debilitating Effects on Nigeria’s Economy: A Legal Approach. Energies 15: 6197-6212.
17.Onwuna DB, Stanley HO, Abu GO, Immanuel OM (2022) Air quality at artisanal crude oil refinery sites in Igia-Ama, Tombia Kingdom, Rivers State, Nigeria. Asian Journal of Advanced Research and Reports 16: 74-83.
18.Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, et al (2021) The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 372-383.
19.Michel SK, Atmakuri A, Von Ehrenstein OS (2024) Systems for rating bodies of evidence used in systematic reviews of air pollution exposure and reproductive and children’s health: a methodological survey. Environmental Health 23: 32-60.
20.Whiting P, Savovi? J, Higgins JP, Caldwell DM, Reeves BC, et al. (2016) ROBIS: a new tool to assess risk of bias in systematic reviews was developed. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 69: 225-234.
21.Honda M, Suzuki N (2020) Toxicities of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons for aquatic animals. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17: 1363-1386.
22.Onakpohor A, Fakinle BS, Sonibare JA, Oke MA, Akeredolu FA (2020) Investigation of air emissions from artisanal petroleum refineries in the Niger-Delta Nigeria. Heliyon 6: 1-9.
23.Zabbey N, Olsson G (2017) Conflicts–oil exploration and water. Global challenges 1: 1600015.
24.Richard G, Izah SC, Ogwu M (2022) Implications of artisanal crude oil refining on sustainable food production in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria. Journal of Environmental Bioremediation and Toxicology 5: 69-77.
25.Adeniran MA, Oladunjoye MA, Doro KO (2023) Soil and groundwater contamination by crude oil spillage: A review and implications for remediation projects in Nigeria. Frontiers in Environmental Science 11: 1137496.
26.Osuagwu ES, Olaifa E (2018) Effects of oil spills on fish production in the Niger Delta. PloS one 13: 01-14.
27.Al Qaisee GS, Aymen RM, Mahdi EM (2020) Black oil leakage influence on the physical and engineering properties of faw soil. Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University 55: 1-8.
28.Douglas SI, Cornelius BT (2018) Impacts of artisanal crude oil refining activities on soil microorganisms. Journal of Advances in Biology & Biotechnology 20: 1-9.
29.Oba A, John B, Garba J, Oba AJ, John KV, et al. (2022) Bioprospecting of Hydrocarbonoclastic Representative Bacteria. Journal of Environmental Protection 13: 449-458.
30.Yakubu OH (2017) Particle (soot) pollution in Port Harcourt Rivers State, Nigeria -double air pollution burden? Understanding and tackling potential environmental public health impacts. Environments 5: 02-24.
31.Onwuna DB, Stanley HO, Abu GO, Immanuel OM (2023) Perceived impact of soot pollution on residents near artisanal crude oil refineries in Tombia community, Rivers State, Nigeria. FUDMA Journal of Sciences 7: 304-308.
32.Domingo JL, Rovira J (2020) Effects of air pollutants on the transmission and severity of respiratory viral infections. Environmental Research 187: 1-7.
33.Lee YG, Lee PH, Choi SM, An MH, Jang AS (2021) Effects of air pollutants on airway diseases. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 18: 9905-9922.
34.Tran HM, Tsai FJ, Lee YL, Chang JH, Chang LT, et al. (2023) The impact of air pollution on respiratory diseases in an era of climate change: A review of the current evidence. Science of the Total Environment 898: 166340.
35.Duan RR, Hao K, Yang T (2020) Air pollution and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Chronic Diseases and Translational Medicine 6: 260-269.
36.Lee BJ, Kim B, Lee K (2014) Air pollution exposure and cardiovascular disease. Toxicological Research 30: 71-75.
37.Simkhovich BZ, Kleinman MT, Kloner RA (2008) Air pollution and cardiovascular injury: epidemiology, toxicology, and mechanisms. Journal of the American College of Cardiology 52: 719-726.
38.Hamanaka RB, Mutlu GM (2018) Particulate matter air pollution: effects on the cardiovascular system. Frontiers in Endocrinology 9: 01-15.
39.Mitku AA, Zewotir T, North D, Jeena P, Asharam K, et al. (2023) Impact of ambient air pollution exposure during pregnancy on adverse birth outcomes: Generalized structural equation modeling approach. BMC Public Health 23: 45-57.
40.Rani P, Dhok A (2023) Effects of pollution on pregnancy and infants. Cureus 15: 1-7.
41.Brook RD, Rajagopalan S, Pope III CA, Brook JR, Bhatnagar A, et al. (2010) Particulate matter air pollution and cardiovascular disease: an update to the scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation 121: 2331- 2378.
42.Abdel Shafy HI, Mansour MS (2016) A review on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: source, environmental impact, effect on human health and remediation. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum 25: 107-123.
43.Montaño Soto MT, Garza Ocañas L (2014) Health effects due to exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons from the petroleum reining industry. Medicina universitaria 16: 136-140.
44.Patel AB, Shaikh S, Jain KR, Desai C, Madamwar D (2020) Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: sources, toxicity, and remediation approaches. Frontiers in Microbiology 11: 01-23.
45.Beykzade M, Beykzade S (2020) Management evaluate and review solutions to reduce soil pollution. SPECTA Journal of Technology 4: 1-8.
46.Snyder R (2012) Leukemia and benzene. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 9: 2875-2893.
47.Stenehjem JS, Robsahm TE, Bråtveit M, Samuelsen SO, Kirkeleit J, et al. (2017) Aromatic hydrocarbons and risk of skin cancer by anatomical site in 25 000 male offshore petroleum workers. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 60: 679-688.
48.Massányi P, Massányi M, Madeddu R, Stawarz R, Luká? N (2020) Effects of cadmium, lead, and mercury on the structure and function of reproductive organs. Toxics 8: 094-125.
49.Lei HL, Wei HJ, Ho HY, Liao KW, Chien LC (2015) Relationship between risk factors for infertility in women and lead, cadmium, and arsenic blood levels: a cross-sectional study from Taiwan. BMC Public Health 15: 01-11.
50.Lin J, Lin X, Qiu J, You X, Xu J (2023) Association between heavy metals exposure and infertility among American women aged 20–44 years: a cross-sectional analysis from 2013 to 2018 NHANES data. Frontiers in Public Health 11: 1-9.
51.McClam M, Liu J, Fan Y, Zhan T, Zhang Q, et al. (2023) Associations between exposure to cadmium, lead, mercury and mixtures and women’s infertility and long-term amenorrhea. Archives of Public Health 81: 161-182.
52.Kumar P, Brander L, Kumar M, Cuijpers P (2023) Planetary Health and Mental Health Nexus: Benefit of Environmental Management. Annals of Global Health 89: 01-18.
53.Nriagu J, Udofia EA, Ekong I, Ebuk G (2016) Health risks associated with oil pollution in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 13: 346-369.
54.Wigand ME, Timmermann C, Scherp A, Becker T, Steger F (2022) Climate change, pollution, deforestation, and mental health: Research trends, gaps, and ethical considerations. GeoHealth 6: 01-15.
55.Nwinyi OC, Uyi O, Awosanya EJ, Oyeyemi IT, Ugbenyen AM, et al. (2020) Review of drinking water quality in Nigeria: towards attaining the sustainable development goal six. Annals of Science and Technology 5: 58-77.
56.Shayo GM, Elimbinzi E, Shao GN, Fabian C (2023) Severity of waterborne diseases in developing countries and the effectiveness of ceramic filters for improving water quality. Bulletin of the National Research Centre 47: 113-127.
57.Althomali RH, Abbood MA, Saleh EAM, Djuraeva L, Abdullaeva BS, et al. (2024) Exposure to heavy metals and neurocognitive function in adults: a systematic review. Environmental Sciences Europe 36: 01-16.
58.Heng YY, Asad I, Coleman B, Menard L, Benki Nugent S, et al. (2022) Heavy metals and neurodevelopment of children in low and middle-income countries: A systematic review. Plos One 17: 01-25.
59.Onuh MO, Madukwe DK, Ohia GU (2008) Effects of poultry manure and cow dung on the physical and chemical properties of crude oil polluted soil. Science World Journal 3: 45-50.
60. Oyedeji AA, Adebiyi AO, Omotoyinbo MA, Ogunkunle CO (2012) Effect of crude oil-contaminated soil on germination and growth performance of Abelmoschus esculentus L. Moench—a widely cultivated vegetable crop in Nigeria. American Journal of Plant Sciences 3: 1451-1454.
61.Okonokhua BO, Ikhajiagbe B, Anoliefo GO, Emede TO (2007) The effects of spent engine oil on soil properties and growth of maize (Zea mays L). Journal of Applied Sciences and Environmental Management 11: 147-152.
62.Semhi K, Clauer N, Sivakumar N, Al Busaidi W, Al Dhafri K, et al. (2017) Changing elemental uptake of roots and leaves from plants grown on a soil variably polluted by crude oil. International Journal of Earth & Environmental Sciences 2: 1-6.
63.Arellano P, Tansey K, Balzter H, Tellkamp M (2017) Plant family-specific impacts of petroleum pollution on biodiversity and leaf chlorophyll content in the Amazon rainforest of Ecuador. PloS one 12: 01-18.
64.Zhu MF, Deng C, Su HB, You XD, Zhu L, et al. (2013) Oil pollutants degradation of nano-MgO in micro-polluted water. Computational Water, Energy, and Environmental Engineering 2: 12-15.
65.Dong Y, Liu Y, Hu C, MacDonald IR, Lu Y (2022) Chronic oiling in global oceans. Science 376: 1300-1304.
66.Igbani F, Ahulimen RW, Weapngong TG (2024) Effects of illegal refineries on aquatic life in the Niger Delta, Nigeria: A review. International Journal of Environment and Pollution Research 12: 01-17.
67.Efenakpo OD, Chris DI, Onuchukwu NC, Kejeh AC (2022) Illegal crude oil refining and its implications on the Niger Delta’s ecosystem. https://doi.org/10.13140/ RG.2.2.23863.39840
68.Aulsebrook LC, Bertram MG, Martin JM, Aulsebrook AE, Brodin T, et al. (2020) Reproduction in a polluted world: implications for wildlife. Reproduction 160: 13-23.
69.Colborn T, Vom Saal FS, Soto AM (1993) Developmental effects of endocrine-disrupting chemicals in wildlife and humans. Environmental Health Perspectives 101: 378-384.
70.Wu RS, Zhou BS, Randall DJ, Woo NY, Lam PK (2003) Aquatic hypoxia is an endocrine disruptor and impairs fish reproduction. Environmental Science & Technology 37: 1137-1141.
71.Norris A, Burgin S (2011) Answering questions on the impact of recycled water on wildlife using Gambusia holbrooki as a surrogate. Australian Zoologist 35: 1047-1052.
72.Chilvers BL, Ruoppolo V (2023) Planning for an offshore oiled wildlife response: case studies from New Zealand and Brazil. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 30: 54351-54361.
73.John EO, Nnadozie J (2021) Artisanal Crude Refining in Niger Delta and its Impact on the Cultural and Religious Beliefs of the People. GNOSI: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Theory and Praxis 4: 112-124.
74.David UK, Enwa S, Oyita GE, Udeh NH (2023) Effect of oil spills and gas flaring on agriculture and environment: A case of crop farmers in Niger Delta Region of Nigeria (2000-2022). International Journal of Biosciences 22: 30-50.
75.Pomeroy R, Parks J, Mrakovcich KL, LaMonica C (2016) Drivers and impacts of fisheries scarcity, competition, and conflict on maritime security. Marine Policy 67: 94-104.
76.Ordinioha B, Brisibe S (2014) The human health implications of crude oil spills in the Niger delta, Nigeria: An interpretation of published studies. Nigerian Medical Journal 54: 10-16.
77.Zhang X, Xia Q, Lai Y, Wu B, Tian W, et al. (2022) Spatial effects of air pollution on the economic burden of disease: implications of health and environment crisis in a post- COVID-19 world. International Journal for Equity in Health 21: 161-177.
78.Odubo TR, Odubo TV (2022) Policy implementation in the context of environmental degradation, insecurity and poverty: the case of Niger delta region, Nigeria. The Nigerian Journal of Sociology and Anthropology 20: 01-20.
79.Ikezam P, Elenwo EI, Oyegun CU (2021) Effects of artisanal refinery on the environment, public health and socio-economic development of communities in the Niger Delta region. Environmental Management and Sustainable Development 10: 97-111.
80.Ite AE, Ufot UF, Ite MU, Isaac IO, Ibok UJ (2016) Petroleum industry in Nigeria: Environmental issues, national environmental legislation and implementation of international environmental law. American Journal of Environmental Protection 4: 21-37.
81.Azuazu IN, Sam K, Campo P, Coulon F (2023) Challenges and opportunities for low-carbon remediation in the Niger Delta: towards sustainable environmental management. Science of the Total Environment 900: 01-16.
82.Luke ME, Odokuma LO (2021) Acute toxicity of crude oil from NNPC and artisanal refineries in Niger Delta on selected aquatic biota. GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences 15: 16-24.
83.Onyena AP, Sam K (2020) A review of the threat of oil exploitation to mangrove ecosystem: Insights from Niger Delta, Nigeria. Global Ecology and Conservation 22: 01-12.
84.Oruonye ED, Ahmed YM (2020) The role of enforcement in environmental protection in Nigeria. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews 7: 48-56.
View PDF